30 comments to “Crumbs from your table: Bono’s flawed vision for humanitarian relief”

  1. Don Sivyer | August 31, 2007 | Permalink Reply

    Paul

    This response is dead on point, with Mark 8:36 being the summation and centerpiece.
    Hebrews 9:27… “And as it is appointed unto men once to die, but after this the judgment”…. What is the point without Christ?

    Exactly-Exactly-Exactly!

  2. Don Sivyer | September 12, 2007 | Permalink Reply

    I don’t get it. Twelve days on the block and no one takes you to task for a critique of the sacred one. The last time I did I was quartered and drawn.

  3. Kiki D | November 8, 2007 | Permalink Reply

    I just saw this beautiful article. Frankly, im surprised to be the 3rd post. James the apostle really has said it all talking about works in his epistle. While some believe that he contradicted Paul (“the just shall live by faith”) by stressing ‘works’ so much, i believe he complemented Paul beautifully. Good works should be one of the fruits of our faith if we profess to have faith.

    I heard a man of God preach that the rich man in Lazarus’ story went to hades not for being rich, but for ignoring the poor- ‘minding his own business’ as it were.

    And who better to distribute physical relief than those who have received spiritual, eternal relief and who have the power to present it to the unsaved and suffering?

  4. molleth | November 18, 2007 | Permalink Reply

    A friend sent me to this blog today. After reading this post, I doubt I’ll be back.

    When you’ve given your blood for the Africans, then start talking about how they need more of your doctrine and how Bono is misguided for sending them his money without the name of Jesus plastered on it (or is flawed because he’s looking to government for help). Sheesh.

    I have that U2 Album that you quote from, and I don’t think I’ve ever heard a more powerful song of worship than Bono’s “Yahweh,” the last one on the disck. It makes me cry every time I hear it and raise my hands toward heaven. Not that that means much, but still, I can’t help but experience a severe rise in blood pressure when I hear Bono being criticized by the Church for not speaking Christianese enough. It’s amazing the guy has any faith left, given the way we “love” him.

    And as for the way the Church reacts to his desire to help Africa? It’s like the Pharisees haggling over whether or not Jesus should have healed the man’s hand on the Sabbath. I mean, is this writer joking???

    “I’m sorry, you’re not helping starving and dying people through the right organizations. Oh, and you’re not using the right words when you do it.”

    Praise God that Bono is working to alleviate suffering in a part of the world most American Christians try to pretend doesn’t exist. Praise God for that! After you’ve started your own relief agency for Africa, *then* haggle over details on how best to do the job, by all means. But until then, please have some respect for the suffering, who really don’t care whether they get “crumbs” from the fat US church’s potluck, or a “feast” from government bigwigs, or a passionately written blog post about how they can all come to an invisible Table. Why? They’re too busy trying not to die today.

  5. Paul Edwards | November 18, 2007 | Permalink Reply

    Bono wasn’t criticized in the post for not speaking “Christianese.” He was challenged to live the faith he professes by speaking the gospel into deperate situations.

    You point out the fact that AIDS victims in Africa (and I suppose other places, as well) are “too busy trying not to die today” which is PRECISELY why they need the gospel of Jesus Christ ALONG WITH aid for their physical and emotional suffering. If these people DIE, their hope is not Bono’s relief efforts. Their only hope is Jesus’ blood and righteousness. As Bono works to alleviate suffering, he should do it in the context of speaking the gospel to those same souls.

    The post was not a reaction to a desire to help Africa. You have no idea what I am personally doing to relieve suffering in Africa, so who is the real Pharisee here? No one in the church of Jesus Christ is “haggling” over whether or not we should be helping Africa. It seems you are the one standing and beating your chest, pointing how much more righteous you are than the “sinners” in the church (Luke 18:9-14). Again, who is the real Pharisee here?

  6. [...] Scriptura or poke at Grudem’s thoughts on what Creation “clearly” teaches, or yell at people who grump about Bono’s work with dying people!!!  [...]

  7. molleth | November 19, 2007 | Permalink Reply

    I wasn’t trying to say you are a Pharisee. I was just frustrated at the way we (in the Christian community) treat people. Your post is an unfortunate example, in my opinion.

    If you think Bono isn’t doing a good enough job, then go join with him—you can do the salvation message everytime he hands out stuff that saves physical lives. But grumping about someone who is keeping people from dying, all because he’s not doing *enough* or not including the right words, just seems really…weird. He may not buy into your theological view, but he’s out there sacrificing personal comfort to save lives that most of the world is ignoring. Good grief.

    If you don’t like that, please explain Biblically why caring for the “widow and the orphan” is only acceptable when one includes salvation tracts. And in the meantime, start your own organization that will do it “right,” instead of bashing the few people who are at least doing SOMEthing.

    I’m annoyed, and I do apologize for letting that come through my tone. I am just finding it very hard to have any sort of patience for this line of thinking. Again, my apologies.

  8. molleth | November 20, 2007 | Permalink Reply

    http://www.joshuacase.net/archives/2007/11/bono_wave_of_so.html
    Bono commenting on an experience in Africa. This is really powerful and worth watching all the way through.

    After watching it and thinking about your own commentary (one I once agreed with), I am reminded of Mark 9:

    “And John answered him, saying, Master, we saw one casting out devils in thy name, and he followeth not us: and we forbad him, because he followeth not us.

    But Jesus said, Forbid him not: for there is no man which shall do a miracle in my name, that can lightly speak evil of me.

    For he that is not against us is on our part.

    For whosoever shall give you a cup of water to drink in my name, because ye belong to Christ, verily I say unto you, he shall not lose his reward.”

  9. Christian | November 29, 2007 | Permalink Reply

    I’m sorry but throwing Bibles and brochures at those in destitution will not save them from their predicaments on earth.

    How do you expect to lift a nation in severe poverty to God? There is one tricky thing about the Word of God. It is word, which requires literacy and willingness to learn.

    Before those impoverished can learn the word they need to learn how to read and write. Before schools will be established the nations must be out of their current predicament.

    Also, don’t generalize the term “Christian” so much now. In this day there are so many denominations with different views on getting into heaven. For instance, if a member of LDS went to a village in Africa and preached their word, and a UCC member went to that same village, only confusion would arise.

    Don’t hide yourself behind Bible verses to justify everything you say.

    Bono is on the right track. Do not call his work flawed. Let someone else take up the responsibility of bringing Christ to Africa.

    I advise that you change the tone of the argument and bring less heat on Bono, but use him as a positive example.

    Perhaps: If Bono can influence so many people to advocate political and economic change in Africa, we as Christians (watch the denominations) should be able to bring about the spiritual change.

    Keep this article to a rallying cry, instead of a mud thrower.

  10. onemagi5 | December 6, 2007 | Permalink Reply

    to: molleth (Nov 18th post)

    Bless you, and thank you. I agree completely. I am so grateful that folks like Bono (and he is just one of many), are willing to embrace their gifts so fully, and give so much to ALL. Yeah, his song “Yaweh” does the same thing for me. I know the history of the word “Yaweh” is that it was originally symbols, not meant to be harnessed, written down, and owned by those humans who would use it to gain power and dominance over fellow beings. It is the grace and divinity of a universal spirit, a great mystery — its what you see in a baby’s eyes; its the action you take when you do something wonderful for someone else, and they don’t know it was you that did it, and you just take such joy in THEIR joy, expecting nothing back. In short, LOVE.
    Thank you for your wisdom. I know what the cost is for me to sit here in my warm house, with my kitchen full of food, typing on this laptop. There are only so many resources available on the planet, and approximately 1/4 of the world has control over the majority of it. Things are not in balance. I used to feel really ashamed to live in America and have so much, while people are watching their children suffer as they starve to death in other countries. But I have come to know that my shame will not help them. I know that I am a warrior. Warriors are strong, and they use what they are gifted with to help those in need. I pray for awareness, and for everyone to let go of needing to control and hoard because they are so AFRAID.
    I pray that I can continue on my journey of answering the calling that is carried on the wind, and be the change that I most dearly want to see in this world.
    I’m glad you’re out there. Keep the faith; spread the word; and bless you.
    onemagi5

  11. Jayne | December 8, 2007 | Permalink Reply

    bono is the ONE person who, if i could pick anyone walking the earth today, would be the one i’d want to have lunch with

    man alive, folks

    what backhanded compliments. you think it’s great he does ‘this’ but take him to task for not doing ‘that’

    no single person can do everything

    stephen was chosen to serve, wasn’t he? why isn’t it enough that bono do what he’s been called to do?

    i hear “The Message” in their music…especially all the tracks the christian artists recorded on “in the name of love, artists united for africa”

    and who was it who said to “preach the gospel at all times, and if necessary, use words”?

  12. Joel | December 9, 2007 | Permalink Reply

    Jayne said: and who was it who said to “preach the gospel at all times, and if necessary, use words”?

    St. Francis of Assisi, AKA not Jesus.

    “Go therefore and MAKE DISCIPLES of all nations, BAPTIZING them in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit, TEACHING them to observe all that I have commanded you. And behold, I am with you always, to the end of the age.”

    By the way, I am a huge U2 fan. The Joshua Tree changed my life. So don’t call me an ignorant idiot just because I think Bono has flaws. What he’s doing for Africa is incredible and I highly respect him for it.

  13. goodhand | December 15, 2007 | Permalink Reply

    this is so sad….i’ve seen and heard this divide within the larger community who claim to be christians……….if we did one tenth of what bono was doing………do you think hearts would change in those who receive? think about it…………i believe they would!! it may not be ‘salvation’ but sure as heck would lay the groundwork for a literal witnessing of mercy and grace…..an example of what the love of christ does, or should do………uggggh………criticizing something done in good faith…..is ugly….

  14. don sivyer | February 5, 2008 | Permalink Reply

    Mark 8:36
    For what shall it profit a man, if he shall gain the whole world, and lose his own soul? Jesus

    How do we find ourselves here? don

  15. Nancy Scott | March 31, 2008 | Permalink Reply

    I don’t believe what we have here is a complaint against anything Bono or the Gates have done, it is rather a focusing in on the true mission of the church. Yes, relieve suffering where and when you can…this is a VERY GOOD THING…but, always point the way to Jesus and what he has done as our ultimate means of deliverance from a DEAD END life. Resources however great will eventually fail…the human hand will tire, or grow weary. We need an eternal view point.

    Jesus told us that it was to our benefit for Him to go to be with the Father so that the Comforter would come. He too was bound by the physical limitations of humanity. Because He was eternity minded, we all, who have reached out to Him have been given the ultimate connection to the SOURCE OF LIFE ITSELF.

    Can we have both of these views of ministry on their own? Yes, but we shouldn’t have to; they go lovingly hand in hand. But the real argument is…which is better, to give a man a fish…or to teach him how to fish?

  16. Chris Campbell | May 13, 2008 | Permalink Reply

    Scene: Bono at the judgment

    Jesus: ‘Come, you who are blessed by my Father. Inherit the kingdom prepared for you from the foundation of the world.”

    Bono: What? Who me?

    Jesus: When I was hungry and you gave me food, I was thirsty and you gave me drink, a stranger and you welcomed me, naked and you clothed me, ill and you cared for me, in prison and you visited me.’

    Bono: when did I see you hungry and feed you, or thirsty and give you drink?

    Jesus: ‘Amen, I say to you, whatever you did for one of these least brothers of mine, you did for me.’

    Corporal works of Mercy
    1. Feed the hungry
    2. Give drink to the thirsty
    3. Clothe the naked
    4. Shelter the homeless
    5. Visit the sick
    6. Visit those in prison
    7. Bury the dead

    Spiritual works of Mercy

    1. Convert the sinner
    2. Instruct the ignorant
    3. Counsel the doubtful
    4. Comfort the sorrowful
    5. Bear wrongs patiently
    6. Forgive injuries
    7. Pray for the living and the dead

    I think bono and gates are right in line with the church’s mission. Not all are preachers.

    Preach the Gospel always. Use words only when necessary. (Francis of Assisi)

  17. Nancy Scott | May 17, 2008 | Permalink Reply

    I really liked your post Chris. It reminds me of conversations that I’ve had with a long time close friend. We all are called to action by the Holy Spirit, working through the personality that the Father has given us. My first reaction (mostly) to any problem, or joy is to pray and ask for a plan of action. My friend on the other hand always wants to get in and get her hands IN action. Many times I have heard her say…I don’t want to just PRAY! We make a great team *: ) My personality says: Pray first then jump. Hers says: Jump first and get the praying done before your feet hit the ground. *: ) I really LOVE this friend and we have had many wonderful adventures together.

  18. Nancy Scott | May 17, 2008 | Permalink Reply

    Hmmm, guess I just played the Martha and Mary combination card. *; )

  19. Chris Campbell | May 22, 2008 | Permalink Reply

    Nancy I get the impression hanging with your friend can get exciting / crazy at times. There are a few Martha’s at my church – they always seem to know what to do and how to do it. I’m a ready volunteer to help them when I can.

    By experience reaction is to pray also. In the few instances I’ve tried to lead / plan the results were more Peter-like. Peter being the biggest nit-wit in the bible. Like him, with the exception of my belief, everything I say or do comes out wrong.

  20. Nancy Scott | May 23, 2008 | Permalink Reply

    Yeah, we’re all nit-wits until the Holy Spirit gets ahold of us! *: ) Then we mercifully are changed to half-wits and then move on to three-quarter-wits. None of us will get ALL our wits until Jesus returns.

  21. tinscotty | June 10, 2008 | Permalink Reply

    We live in a world today where if someone only does good works and never speaks except when neccessary, many people seeing the deeds will not know to glorify our father in heaven. We need to do good works that he planned before hand for us to walk in, but we must always (also) tell the gosple otherwise, how do we glorify Jesus? They will not know that you are christian. People always have preconcived ideas about everything and unless we talk about Jesus when we help, they will probably not know that we do it because we are christian.

  22. b/Bo | September 17, 2008 | Permalink Reply

    Great post (#16), Chris!

    The good news of the kingdom that Jesus brought was not “pray this prayer and you get to go to heaven when you die” – that perversion was invented recently in church history. Whether or not the good works Bono is encouraging and doing himself include a speech on the superiority of the way of Jesus or not, the actions themselves are good and right and just and merciful, and in keeping with the kingdom. I thank God for Bono, Bill, Melinda, and every soul practicing kingdom-minded principles, even if only in part. I’d venture that teaching people the way of Jesus is a lot easier with some food in their bellies, some medicine flowing through their system, and some ointment and bandages on their wounds than without these acts. Heck, just doing that you HAVE taught them part of the way of Jesus. May His kingdom increase!

  23. Nancy | September 18, 2008 | Permalink Reply

    I tend to see this statement a lot…

    “The good news of the kingdom that Jesus brought was not “pray this prayer and you get to go to heaven when you die”

    The “prayer” NEVER saved anyone…it is simply finding words to proclaim what has happened in your heart…If it were the “prayer”…it would exclude the deaf mute and possibly others…The “prayer” is also not a problem…words will not negate the work of the Holy Spirit in someones heart…The words…or the “prayer” are a point of contact to express and proclaim the wonder that has just happened…

    10For with the heart man believeth unto righteousness; and with the mouth confession is made unto salvation.

    Romans 10:10

    Because we believe…we speak
    Because we love…we share

  24. b/Bo | September 18, 2008 | Permalink Reply

    Context, Nancy – you’re not using that verse as it was intended.

    Jesus said “FOLLOW ME”. Jesus commissioned his disciples to MAKE DISCIPLES (literally Talmidim who learn to become just like the Rabbi). It’s a “do what I do” proposition, not a one-time proclaiming of some kind of “wonder that has just happened”.

    Because we believe, we speak and DO. But we’re not trying to get people into heaven when they die, we’re trying to get them to embrace the wisdom and beauty of his reign in the lives of his called-out community that is both kingdom and church.

    I suspect you’ll continue to see that statement more and more as this generation rises up to reject our corrupt two-party system, radical militant reaction, and isolationism and embrace the true gospel of Jesus Christ that restores the world. I also suspect that most on this site will fight against it because it violates their tradition. But even from that there will be a Nicodemus and a Joseph of Arimathea yet to slip out and embrace the truth. :)

  25. Nancy | September 19, 2008 | Permalink Reply

    Actually, the kingdom, whether heavenly or earthly is merely a sideline issue…the point of the Gospel is to bring people into relationship with the Father. From there…all things are possible…from there we inherit the kingdom (both earthly and heavenly) …from there we receive life abundant and life eternal…

    And this is life eternal, that they might know thee the only true God, and Jesus Christ, whom thou hast sent.

    John 17:3

  26. b/Bo | September 19, 2008 | Permalink Reply

    The kingdom is not a sideline issue, it is the heart of the gospel. Jesus came preaching the good news of the kingdom of God/Heaven – go ahead look it up and you’ll be surprised at how many times that language is used in scripture.

    God’s mission is not to save individuals, it’s to create a COMMUNITY of individuals (call it the church, the kingdom, God’s people, whatever) who love him and honor him and do his will. This group of people (Jew/Gentile, male/female, slave/free) is all about restoration in the four directions I mentioned earlier (God, self, others, creation). This restoration IS the good news, the “gospel”.

    We are not destined for heaven permanently – it’s a temporary place until the heavens and earth are restored, at which point the resurrected will inhabit it along with those who are still alive.

    I fear your gospel is too small and too individualized, which is unfortunately very American.

  27. Nancy | September 19, 2008 | Permalink Reply

    “…all about restoration in the four directions I mentioned earlier (God, self, others, creation). This restoration IS the good news, the “gospel”.

    So we agree it is about relationship, relationship, relationship…relationship…*: )

  28. Nancy | September 19, 2008 | Permalink Reply

    Might we just state the obvious…The Kingdom…any kingdom…without the required relationship…can become ugly really fast.

  29. Jeff (AKA Pixelmaster) | September 22, 2008 | Permalink Reply

    Bob,

    “I fear your gospel is too small and too individualized, which is unfortunately very American.”

    I honestly feel this move is happening right underneath the nose of the church. The church has done all it can to squash it but the issue is that once the message is revealed it makes so much sense that it is impossible to resist. God is raising up a community of believers that resist the old norms. Us vs them, Us vs us, etc, it is not longer about being separate but taking the entire message of Christ to the world for true reconciliation. We no longer see the 1 aspect of personal salvation as the only most important and thus only thing the world needs to hear. As we have witnessed, the church as taken on it’s personal salvation message and applied it to themselves. What can we do to build the church to make it more appealing to the world so they will come. They build mini empires that only glorify ourselves. The message of the Kingdom is about reconciliation, it is about restoration, it is about come one come all, the kingdom is open to all. Personally, used to follow a movement to squash the emergent church movement, however, once I read a book by one of the authors it opened up a whole new world. One that loves the lost more then ever, one that views all humans as in God’s image no matter what worldview. One that wants to take Christ to the world and not hide him in the tiny box of the Christian subculture, he is too good to keep to ourselves.

  30. Derek Scott | November 5, 2008 | Permalink Reply

    Taking Christ to people on God’s terms not ours, or Bono’s, or the culture, or the cats on TV, or Radio is really the question. Truly any other logic might seem right, but in the end death sits with open arms waiting to rip you apart.

    There is The Book out there…that told me we’re not to lean on our own understanding. In fact, in the Book, there is one that did: Judas who most likely knew the Old-Test, was called, had a position, was an apostle, heard the messages, took Jesus to others, witnessed miracles, shoot he might have even seen the crucifixion.

    The same fate awaits many who walk a wide road.

    Lord Jesus, grant me your logic.

Leave a Reply

Contact Paul